Long Island Brothers New York Pizza Long Island Brothers New York Pizza
  • Home
  • Menu
  • About
  • Photos
  • Reviews
  • Location
  • Long Island Brothers New York Pizza


    3812 Skyline Blvd, Cape Coral, FL 33914, United States


  • Long Island Brothers New York Pizza


    +1 239-837-8221


Service options

+ Delivery

+ Takeaway

+ Dine-in

Highlights

+ Serves local specialty

Popular for

+ Lunch

+ Dinner

+ Solo dining

Accessibility

+ Wheelchair-accessible car park

+ Wheelchair-accessible entrance

+ Wheelchair-accessible seating

Offerings

+ Comfort food

+ Quick bite

Dining options

+ Lunch

+ Dinner

+ Dessert

Amenities

+ Toilet

Atmosphere

+ Casual

Crowd

+ Groups

+ Tourists

Payments

+ Credit cards

+ Debit cards

Children

+ Good for kids

Parking

+ Free of charge street parking

+ Free parking lot

+ Parking


Long Island Brothers New York Pizza menu

Calzone

Stuffed with Ricotta, Parm, & Mozzarella, Brushed with Garlic Oil.

US$14.00

Caesar Salad

Shaved parm,croutons.

US$13.00

Greek Salad

Tomatos, onions, banana peppers,kalamata ovive,fetta cheese.

US$13.00

Long Island House

Tomatos,green peppers, onions, black olive,croutons.

US$13.00

Caprese

Fresh tomato,fresh mozzarella topped with Basil,balsamic glaze.

US$13.00

Poppa Joes Antipasto

Black olive,green olive,roasted red peppers, artichoke heart, topped with our meat and cheese mix.

US$13.00

Whitestone Bridge Medium

Ricotta,chopped garlic, fresh mozzarella topped with parm and evoo.

US$22.00

Chicken Bacon Ranch Medium

Crispy chicken tossed in ranch with bacon topped with mozzarella.

US$22.00

Full Menu

Discover Long Island Brothers New York Pizza

If you're ever in the Cape Coral area and craving a slice of New York-style pizza, Long Island Brothers New York Pizza is the spot you don't want to miss. Located at 3812 Skyline Blvd, Cape Coral, FL 33914, this charming pizzeria brings the authentic taste of the Big Apple straight to your table. Whether you're a local or just visiting, the atmosphere and flavors here will make you feel like you're in a true New York pizza joint.

Walking into Long Island Brothers, you'll immediately feel at home. The restaurant has that classic, cozy vibe that many of us associate with New York diners and pizzerias. The friendly staff greets you with a warm smile, and you know right away that you're in for a great meal. What stands out here, aside from the excellent service, is the pizza. It's crafted using the finest ingredients, with dough that’s perfectly crisped on the outside and soft on the inside, just the way it should be.

What truly sets Long Island Brothers New York Pizza apart is the way they handle every aspect of the pizza-making process. The dough is made fresh daily, and they take the time to ensure it's just right. Toppings are generous and of the highest quality, with a variety of options to satisfy any craving. From classic margherita to more adventurous choices like buffalo chicken or white pizza, there’s something for everyone on the menu.

Aside from pizza, the restaurant also offers a range of other Italian-American favorites. Their garlic knots are a local favorite, baked to golden perfection and served with a side of marinara. And don’t overlook their pasta dishes-each one is a hearty, flavorful portion that keeps guests coming back for more. The lasagna, in particular, stands out for its rich layers of cheese and savory meat sauce. It’s the perfect comfort food to enjoy with family or friends.

But pizza is the main attraction, and for good reason. The crispy, thin crust and flavorful sauce remind you of the real New York experience. Whether you prefer your pizza with a traditional pepperoni topping or want to explore unique combinations, you can rest assured that Long Island Brothers knows how to do it right. They offer both large and personal-sized pies, making it ideal for everything from a casual solo meal to a group gathering.

What makes this pizzeria even more special is its consistent quality. Local patrons rave about the consistently delicious pies, and the restaurant’s regulars are quick to praise its exceptional service. The staff goes above and beyond to ensure you have a great experience, making it a spot you’ll want to return to time and time again.

Moreover, Long Island Brothers New York Pizza is known for its great value. The prices are reasonable, especially considering the portion sizes and the high-quality ingredients used. If you’re looking for a filling meal without breaking the bank, this is the place to be. Whether you’re grabbing a quick bite on the go or enjoying a leisurely dinner with friends, you’ll get more than your money’s worth.

If you’re planning to visit, it’s worth checking out their hours and location on Skyline Blvd. The convenient spot makes it easy to swing by for a quick lunch or dinner after a day of exploring Cape Coral. Plus, they offer takeout and delivery options, so you can enjoy their mouthwatering pizza from the comfort of your own home.

For those who appreciate a good pizza, the experience at Long Island Brothers is truly one of a kind. The attention to detail, the top-notch ingredients, and the warm, inviting atmosphere make it a must-try for anyone in the area. Whether you're in the mood for a classic slice or something a little different, Long Island Brothers New York Pizza has you covered.


Long Island Brothers New York Pizza Photos

Long Island Brothers New York Pizza Photo -1
Long Island Brothers New York Pizza Photo -2
Long Island Brothers New York Pizza Photo -3
Long Island Brothers New York Pizza Photo -4
Long Island Brothers New York Pizza Photo -5
Long Island Brothers New York Pizza Photo -6
Long Island Brothers New York Pizza Photo -7
Long Island Brothers New York Pizza Photo -8
Long Island Brothers New York Pizza Photo -9
Long Island Brothers New York Pizza Photo -10

Location & Contact

Get in touch with our support team


  • 3812 Skyline Blvd, Cape Coral, FL 33914, United States
  • +1 239-837-8221




Clock


Hours

Our open schedules

Day
Monday 11:00 AM - 08:00 PM
Tuesday 11:00 AM - 08:00 PM
Wednesday 11:00 AM - 08:00 PM
Thursday 11:00 AM - 08:00 PM
Friday 11:00 AM - 09:00 PM
Saturday 11:00 AM - 09:00 PM
Sunday Closed



Reviews

  • My wife and I just moved to Cape Coral. Our first venture, was to find a good East Coast thin crust pizza. Being originally from Philly, I am a Pizza Critic per say. And hard to please. But being honest, we ordered a whole pie, fresh from the oven and it was delicious!! Tried a couple other places in the Cape and none of them even came close to as delicious as this pizza is. We are definitely heading back for sure. The Owner and his helper were super cool. If I had one negative, it would be the door was wide open and their were some flies to contend with. But that does not warrant any reason, to say this pizza isn't DELICIOUS!!

    Shelby GT500
  • Since Leones closed I've been looking for my authentic NY/NJ pizza joint and BAM! I saw nothing but pics and rave reviews on Facebooks Cape Coral pizza critics page and Wife and I tried it today. Boy oh boy did they NOT disappoint! The slices are HUGE! Had mine with meatball, onion and mushroom. ONE SLICE & YOU ARE DONE! My wife and I are thrilled we found our new pizza joint home! I told DJ (the owner or one of the owners) and he was thrilled to hear the good news. You will NOT be disappointed if you try their pizza & food folks!

    USMCSDI
  • Down to earth hard working folks that know how to make a great pie! 3rd time we've ordered here everytime its been great! They also have a hot and ready section for just a slice. My bet is they will be on the Best in Cape Food List before you know it!

    Jason Cottrell
  • I'm a NY-ER, I moved here a month ago and the pizza here is delicious. Love that they actually cook the bottom and brown it. My Yorkies love their crust as well Most pizzeria's locally don't make the pie with the bottom cooked/well done way too doughy... . They are from Long Island obviously and they nailed it.. Will be a regular here for sure.

    Bling New York
  • The pizza is excellent! A great little classic family style pizza place. I only recently found out about the place. I will be back.

    Tony Costa
  • Awesome little pizza place in an unlikely location, yet they stay busy because the food is fabulous

    Adam Hill
  • Incoming Pizza review Let me start by saying that new owners are the most friendly people and are the staple that hold this excellent pizza joint together The Sicilian slice was breathtaking, and I say that with a serious stern face, first bite through the last was bellissimo, the buffalo chicken slice was authentic as if like a slice from roses in Penn Station we will continue to come back and suggest you do the same, Sicilian sauce was sweet and the regular slice had the right herbs and sauce ratio,a Italian punch in the mouth that you were looking for when you say a pizza from New York, best in the Cape hands-down no contest!

    Charles Cheese

Explore More Taste

  • 426 Reviews

    Tonis Gusto Italiano

    Tonis Gusto Italiano

    Italian Restaurant

    Hörder Phoenixseeallee 164, 44263 Dortmund, Germany

  • 663 Reviews

    Sportheim Gebersheim

    Sportheim Gebersheim

    Restaurant

    An d. Hohlen Eiche 9, 71229 Leonberg, Germany

  • 639 Reviews

    Il Casale Del Gusto

    Il Casale Del Gusto

    Restaurant

    Via Pontina, 432, 00128 Roma RM, Italy

  • 1257 Reviews

    Iguana Bar

    Iguana Bar

    Restaurant

    San Juan del Sur, Nicaragua

  • 1133 Reviews

    El Mariachi Restaurant

    El Mariachi Restaurant

    Mexican Restaurant

    289 Hamilton St Unit 291, Albany, NY 12210, United States

Long Island Brothers New York Pizza

Craving authentic New York-style pizza? Long Island Brothers New York Pizza in Cape Coral serves up delicious, hand-tossed pies with fresh ingredients and a cozy vibe you’ll love!

The information here is community-driven and not from an official source. If you are the site owner, we welcome you to contact us.